Scholar Athletes
NAIA Scholar-Athletes - Men
| 2007 | Rodriogo Forti |
| 2010 | Jeremiah Back |
| 2011 | Jeremiah Back |
| 2012 | Kyle Newhouse |
CSCAA Scholar-Athletes - Men
| 2010 | Jeremiah Back |
| 2011 | Jeremiah Back |
| 2011 | Kyle Newhouse |
| 2012 | Kyle Newhouse |
| 2013 | Cameron Brewer (First Team) |
| 2013 | Martino Cervera (First Team) |
| 2013 | Aaron Bean (Honorable Mention) |
| 2014 | Rafael Bertholo (First Team) |
| 2014 | Jose Jesus Morales (First Team) |
| 2015 | Aaron Bean (First Team) |
| 2015 | Torger Torgersen (First Team) |
NAIA Champion of Character - Men
| 2013 | Travis Strachan |
| 2014 | Dalton Baxter |
| 2015 | Torger Torgersen |
NAIA Team Scholar
| 2012 |
CSCAA Team Scholar
| Fall 2011 |
| Spring 2012 |
| Fall 2012 |
| Spring 2013 |