All-Conference Team Honorees
Conference Players of the Year
| 1997 | Sara Adams | Mid-South Conference |
| 1998 | Juliana Filipe | Mid-South Conference |
| 1999 | Juliana Filipe | Mid-South Conference |
| 2001 | Juliana Filipe | Mid-South Conference |
| 2003 | Alessandra Tavoloni | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| 2004 | Camila Mendes | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| 2005 | Alessandra Tavoloni | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| 2008 | Renata Peixoto | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| 2009 | Marcela Salum | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| 2010 | Ashley Hall | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
AAC Offensive Players of the Year
| 2008 | Renata Peixoto |
| 2009 | Marcela Salum |
| 2012 | Aline Dalmedico |
| 2015 | Jessica Austin |
AAC Defensive Players of the Year
| 2009 | Patricia Nardy |
| 2010 | Patricia Nardy |
AAC Golden Boot Winner
| 2003 | Alessandra Tavoloni |
| 2008 | Ashley Hall |
| 2009 | Ashley Hall |
| 2010 | Ashley Hall |
| 2012 | Helen Weber |
Award given to the conference's leading goal scorer
All-Conference Team Members
| 1994 | Heather Pez |
| 1994 | Erin Raible |
| 1995 | Sara Adams |
| 1995 | Christy Hart |
| 1995 | Erin Raible |
| 1996 | Sara Adams |
| 1996 | Kelly Evans |
| 1996 | Erin Raible |
| 1997 | Sara Adams |
| 1997 | Kelly Evans |
| 1998 | Sara Adams |
| 1998 | Jenny Boles |
| 1998 | Juliana Filipe |
| 1998 | Renee Fox |
| 1998 | Jenny Maxey |
| 1998 | Jena Moorleghen |
| 1999 | Ana Bruni |
| 1999 | Amber Colvin |
| 1999 | Kelly Evans |
| 1999 | Juliana Filipe |
| 1999 | Molly Kirchner |
| 1999 | Jenny Maxey |
| 1999 | Elaine Stappenback |
| 2000 | Ana Bruni |
| 2000 | Jeri Cook |
| 2000 | Paula Fantini |
| 2000 | Juliana Filipe |
| 2000 | Maggie George |
| 2000 | Veronica George |
| 2001 | Kiki Alimonos |
| 2001 | Ana Bruni |
| 2001 | Jeri Cook |
| 2001 | Paula Fantini |
| 2001 | Juliana Filipe |
| 2001 | Maggie George |
| 2001 | Veronica George |
| 2001 | Molly Kirchner |
| 2001 | Camila Mendes |
| 2001 | Allison Parman |
| 2001 | Margaret Rau |
| 2002 | Kiki Alimonos |
| 2002 | Carla Bissotto |
| 2002 | Ana Bruni |
| 2002 | Maggie George |
| 2002 | Camila Mendes |
| 2002 | Alessandra Tavoloni |
| 2003 | Kiki Alimonos |
| 2003 | Danielle Campbell |
| 2003 | Paula Fantini |
| 2003 | Maggie George |
| 2003 | Canila Mendes |
| 2003 | Alessandra Tavoloni |
| 2003 | Becki Woodworth |
| 2004 | Whitney Bundy |
| 2004 | Tanja Harju |
| 2004 | Angie Herr |
| 2004 | Camila Mendes |
| 2004 | Alessandra Tavoloni |
| 2004 | Amanda Weber |
| 2004 | Becki Woodworth |
| 2005 | Anne Castro |
| 2005 | Estefania Cirigliano |
| 2005 | Tanja Harju |
| 2005 | Alessandra Tavoloni |
| 2005 | Amanda Weber |
| 2006 | Anne Castro |
| 2006 | Heather Jaques |
| 2007 | Heather Jaques |
| 2007 | Kara Goncalves |
| 2008 | Ashley Hall |
| 2008 | Renata Pexioto |
| 2008 | Heather Jaques |
| 2008 | Marcela Salum |
| 2008 | Ashleigh Mensch |
| 2009 | Jessica Brandner |
| 2009 | Jessica Florence |
| 2009 | Ashley Hall |
| 2009 | Patrica Nardy |
| 2009 | Renata Peixoto |
| 2009 | Marcela Salum |
| 2009 | Stephanie Cagel |
| 2009 | Jenn Sckirl |
| 2009 | Hannah Goins |
| 2009 | Amy Vallandingham |
| 2010 | Jessica Brandner |
| 2010 | Ashley Hall |
| 2010 | Patricia Nardy |
| 2010 | Renata Peixoto |
| 2010 | Stephanie Cagel |
| 2010 | Jenn Sckirl |
| 2010 | Heather Price |
| 2010 | Kristina Kirk |
| 2011 | Kayse Cornett |
| 2011 | Nikki Jeck |
| 2011 | Sofie Jorgensen |
| 2011 | Kristina Kirk |
| 2011 | Jenn Sckirl |
| 2011 | Helen Weber |
| 2012 | Helen Weber |
| 2012 | Aline Dalmedico |
| 2012 | Sofie Jorgensen |
| 2012 | Casey Camargo |
| 2012 | Stephanie Burton |
| 2012 | Kayse Cornett |
| 2013 | Aline Dalmedico |
| 2013 | Kayse Cornett |
| 2013 | Morgan Hiles |
| 2014 | Aline Dalmedico |
| 2014 | Kendall Ellington |
| 2015 | Jessica Austin |
| 2015 | Tuany Miguel |
| 2016 | Tuany Miguel (first team) |
| 2016 | Carla Delgado (second team) |
| 2019 | Hailee Hinthorne (second team) |
| 2019 | Anna Vila (second team) |
| 2022 | Madison Hebert (second team) |
NOTE: Union was a member of the KIAC from 1993-95, a member of the Mid-South Conference from 1996-2001, and a member of the Appalachian Athletic Conference from 2002-present